Best Aftermarket Car Key Fobs That Actually Work: 8 Reliable Picks

The best aftermarket car key fobs match your original key exactly. We compare 8 smart keys, flip keys and remotes, with programming routes and why cheap fobs fail.

Reader-supported: as an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. How we make money

Best Aftermarket Car Key Fobs That Actually Work: 8 Reliable Picks
Buyer's guide

Best aftermarket car key fobs that actually work

<p>An aftermarket key fob can cost a fraction of a dealer key, but the reviews tell a mixed story: one buyer gets a fob that works for years, the next gets one that never programs. The best aftermarket car key fobs are not magic. They are the ones that match your original key's FCC ID, part number, frequency and chip exactly, come pre-tested from a seller that answers questions, and have a clear programming route.</p><p>We picked eight aftermarket fobs from sellers with published fitment details, split them into smart keys for push-button-start cars and remotes or flip keys for cars with a key ignition, and explain why cheap fobs fail so you can avoid a dud.</p>

In this guide
  • Eight aftermarket fobs with exact FCC IDs and part numbers
  • Which ones you can program yourself and which need a locksmith
  • Why aftermarket fobs fail, and how to avoid a dud
Key Takeaways

Key takeaways

  • Match every code An aftermarket fob only works if its FCC ID, part number, frequency and chip type match your original. Look on the back of your key or under the battery cover.
  • Smart keys usually need a pro Most push-start smart keys need a locksmith’s tool. Some Fords are the exception: you can add a key yourself with two working keys.
  • Basic remotes are often DIY Separate remotes and many flip-key remotes program with a door-and-ignition routine, but the blade still has to be cut and the chip programmed to start the car.
  • Buy before you lose your last key Adding a key is cheap and simple while one still works. Losing every key usually means a locksmith or dealer visit.
Quick picks

Our best aftermarket car key fob picks at a glance

Updated: 1 hour ago
Keyless2Go Replacement for 5 Button Ford Proximity Smart Key for Ford M3N-A2C31243300 164-R8117
5 buttons DIY with 2 keys
A Keyless2Go prox key for 2013–2017 Fords with remote start that you can add yourself if you already have two working keys.
Amazon.com
BUY NOW
Keyless2Go Replacement for Keyless Remote 4 Button Flip Car Key Fob For OHT01060512
Flip key DIY remote setup
A complete flip key for select GM cars and SUVs, with battery, free DIY instructions and tech support.
Amazon.com
BUY NOW
KEYS4LESS Replacement Key Fob Compatible with CX-5 2017-2019 FCC WAZSKE13D02 Part Number TK52-67-5DY TK52675DY
Mazda CX-5 smart key Most complete kit
4 buttons Blade included
Arrives pre-tested with the battery and emergency blade already fitted.
Amazon.com
BUY NOW
USARemote Key Fob Replacement Keyless Entry Remote for 2016 2017 Honda Accord 5-Button Smart Key (ACJ932HK1310A, 72147-T2G-A31)
5 buttons Remote start
A 5-button ACJ932HK1310A smart key for 2016–2017 Accords with remote start.
Amazon.com
BUY NOW
Discount Keyless Key Fob Keyless Entry Car Remote for Nissan Infiniti KBRASTU15, CWTWB1U733 (2 Pack)
2 remotes Self-program
Two basic keyless remotes for older key-start Nissan and Infiniti models that you program yourself.
Amazon.com
BUY NOW

Best aftermarket car key fobs: smart key, flip key, remote head key and keyless remote on a garage workbench

Side-by-side comparison

Aftermarket smart keys compared (push-button start)

Best overall
Ford smart key
Toyota SUVs
Highlander key
Complete kit
Mazda CX-5 key
Honda
Accord key
Keyless2Go Replacement for 5 Button Ford Proximity Smart Key for Ford M3N-A2C31243300 164-R8117 SUPALAND Smart Key Fob Keyless Entry Fits for Toyota Highlander 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Remote Control Key Replacement HYQ14FBA, 281451-2110 (AG Board) 4 Buttons KEYS4LESS Replacement Key Fob Compatible with CX-5 2017-2019 FCC WAZSKE13D02 Part Number TK52-67-5DY TK52675DY USARemote Key Fob Replacement Keyless Entry Remote for 2016 2017 Honda Accord 5-Button Smart Key (ACJ932HK1310A, 72147-T2G-A31)
Fits 2013–17 Ford 2014–19 Highlander 2017–19 CX-5 2016–17 Accord
Buttons 5 4 4 5
FCC ID M3N-A2C31243300 HYQ14FBA WAZSKE13D02 ACJ932HK1310A
Programming DIY (2 keys) Locksmith Locksmith Locksmith
Our score 9.1 /10 8.8 /10 8.6 /10 8.5 /10
Price – – – –
View View View View
Side-by-side comparison

Aftermarket remotes and flip keys compared (key ignition)

Best value
GM flip key
Two-pack
Toyota 2-pack
Jeep
Jeep head key
Budget
Nissan 2-pack
Keyless2Go Replacement for Keyless Remote 4 Button Flip Car Key Fob For OHT01060512 SUPALAND Key Fob Replacement fits for 2014-2017 Toyota Camry / 2014-2019 Corolla / 2016-2018 Tacoma Car Keyless Entry Remote Control Key with H Chip, HYQ12BDM HYQ12BEL, 4 Buttons (Set of 2) MechanMagic Key Fob Replacement Fits for Jeep Patriot Compass 2010-2017, Wrangler 2007-2018, Dodge Caliber Ram Nitro (FCC ID:OHT692713A,OHT692427AA, KOBDT04A) Remote Keyless Head Key 315MHZ 46 Chip Discount Keyless Key Fob Keyless Entry Car Remote for Nissan Infiniti KBRASTU15, CWTWB1U733 (2 Pack)
Fits Select GM Corolla, Camry, Tacoma Wrangler, Compass Older Nissan
FCC ID OHT01060512 HYQ12BDM OHT692427AA KBRASTU15
Programming DIY remote Locksmith Locksmith DIY
Key blade Uncut Uncut Uncut None
Our score 9.0 /10 8.7 /10 8.4 /10 8.3 /10
Price – – – –
View View View View
Methodology

How we chose these aftermarket car key fobs

We did not program every fob into a test car. We compared listings, FCC IDs, part numbers and seller instructions against OEM key catalogs from locksmith suppliers, and weighed the problems locksmiths and owners report with cheap fobs.

  • Exact codes on the listing

    Every pick lists its FCC ID and OEM part numbers, and the smart keys name the board or chip version, so you can check it against your original before you buy.

  • Pre-tested units

    We favored sellers that say each fob is tested before shipping and that include the battery and electronics already fitted.

  • A clear programming route

    Each listing says plainly whether you can program it yourself or need a locksmith or dealer. Vague “easy programming” claims counted against a product.

  • Seller support

    Keyless2Go, for example, includes free tech support and DIY programming instructions. Being able to ask a question before ordering prevents most wrong-fob purchases.

Aftermarket smart keys for push-button start: detailed reviews

01 Best overall
Keyless2Go 5-Button Ford Proximity Smart Key (M3N-A2C31243300, 164-R8117)

The 5-button smart key Ford used from 2013 to 2017, with lock, unlock, trunk, panic and remote start

5 buttons Remote start DIY with 2 keys

This is the one smart key on our list most owners can set up themselves. Keyless2Go says you can program it at home if you already have two working keys. Without them, a locksmith or dealer has to do it. It replaces FCC ID M3N-A2C31243300 and part number 164-R8117, the 5-button key with remote start used on 2013–2017 Ford models such as the Fusion, Edge and Explorer.

The fob comes fully assembled with its battery, pre-tested, with a link to DIY instructions and free tech support. Check that your original has five buttons including remote start. Ford also made a 4-button key (M3N-A2C31243800) that this one does not replace.

Best for
2013–2017 Ford owners with two working smart keys
Not for
Fords with the 4-button smart key
Pros
  • You can add it yourself with two working keys
  • Free tech support and DIY instructions
  • Battery fitted and pre-tested
Cons
  • Needs two working keys for DIY setup
  • Only for the 5-button remote-start key
  • Emergency blade may need cutting
02 Best for Toyota SUVs
SUPALAND Smart Key Fob for 2014–2019 Toyota Highlander (HYQ14FBA, AG Board)

A Highlander smart key that names its board version, which is what makes Toyota keys work

4 buttons AG board Push start

Toyota smart keys that share FCC ID HYQ14FBA come with different internal boards, and the board has to match your car. SUPALAND lists this one as the AG board (281451-2110) for part numbers 89904-0E120 and 89904-0E121, which fit the 2014–2019 Highlander and 2020–2021 Sequoia. That level of detail is exactly what separates a fob that works from one that doesn’t.

It is not on-board programmable: a locksmith or dealer has to program the smart key and cut the emergency blade. The fob arrives with electronics and battery installed and is tested before shipping.

Best for
2014–2019 Highlander owners with a 4-button smart key
Not for
Anyone hoping to program it at home
Pros
  • Lists the exact board version
  • Battery and electronics pre-installed
  • Tested before shipping
Cons
  • Needs professional programming
  • Blade must be cut
  • Only fits AG-board Highlanders and Sequoias
03 Most complete kit
KEYS4LESS Smart Key Fob for 2017–2019 Mazda CX-5 (WAZSKE13D02, TK52-67-5DY)

A complete 4-button smart key with the emergency blade already fitted

4 buttons Blade included Pre-tested

KEYS4LESS ships this CX-5 smart key fully assembled with the electronics, battery and emergency key blade, and says every unit is pre-tested for signal strength. It replaces FCC ID WAZSKE13D02 with part numbers TK52-67-5DY and TK52675DY for the 2017–2019 Mazda CX-5.

A locksmith or automotive professional has to program it and cut the blade, and a working key is typically needed to add a new one. Mazda used the same FCC ID on other part numbers, so match the part number on your key, not just the FCC ID.

Best for
2017–2019 CX-5 owners adding a spare
Not for
Owners who have lost every key
Pros
  • Emergency blade included
  • Pre-tested for signal strength
  • Clear part-number fitment
Cons
  • Needs professional programming
  • Working key usually needed
  • Narrow 2017–2019 fitment
04 Best for Honda
USARemote 5-Button Smart Key for 2016–2017 Honda Accord (ACJ932HK1310A, 72147-T2G-A31)

The Accord’s 5-button smart key with remote start and trunk

5 buttons Remote start 433 MHz class

Honda keys are a common source of programming trouble, so this listing’s honesty helps: USARemote states that the key must be programmed by an automotive locksmith or dealership and cannot be self-programmed. It replaces FCC ID ACJ932HK1310A, part number 72147-T2G-A31, the 5-button smart key for the 2016–2017 Accord.

Check your year, make and model before ordering. Accord keys with seat memory exist in separate Driver 1 and Driver 2 versions at OEM key suppliers, so if your car has memory seats, ask the seller which version you are getting.

Best for
2016–2017 Accord owners with remote start
Not for
DIY buyers
Pros
  • Matches the 5-button remote-start layout
  • Clear about professional programming
  • Lower cost than a dealer key
Cons
  • Cannot be self-programmed
  • Only for 2016–2017 Accords
  • Memory-seat versions need checking

Programming an aftermarket car key fob with a handheld tool plugged into the OBD port

Aftermarket remotes and flip keys for key-start cars: detailed reviews

05 Best value
Keyless2Go 4-Button Flip Key for Select GM Vehicles (OHT01060512)

A complete GM flip key with battery, key ring and free DIY instructions

Flip key Remote start layout DIY remote

This flip key replaces part numbers OHT01060512, 20873622, 20835400 and 20873620 used on many GM cars and SUVs. It’s a complete remote with all electronics and battery, plus an uncut blade, and Keyless2Go sends a link to free DIY programming instructions with every order. Canadian vehicles need a locksmith or dealer.

Read the fine print: it will not work on cars with passive (proximity) entry, and if your original has remote start, that button must sit directly below the lock button. The blade still has to be cut, and the chip programmed, before the key can start the car.

Best for
GM owners with a 4-button flip key
Not for
GM cars with push-button start
Pros
  • Low price for a complete flip key
  • Free DIY instructions and tech support
  • Battery and key ring included
Cons
  • Blade must be cut and chip programmed
  • Not for passive-entry GM models
  • Canadian vehicles need a pro
06 Best two-pack
SUPALAND Toyota Remote Head Key, H Chip, 2-Pack (HYQ12BDM, HYQ12BEL)

Two remote head keys for the Corolla, Camry and Tacoma

2 keys H chip 4 buttons

You get two 4-button remote head keys in this set, each with its electronics board and battery pre-installed and tested before shipping. They replace FCC IDs HYQ12BDM and HYQ12BEL with part number 89070-02880 and use the H chip that 2014–2019 Corolla (USA), 2014–2017 Camry and 2016–2018 Tacoma models need.

The H chip matters: Toyota keys from earlier years use G or 4D chips that won’t start these cars. A locksmith or dealer has to cut and program both keys, which often costs less per key when done together.

Best for
Toyota owners who want two spares
Not for
Push-start Toyotas
Pros
  • Two keys in one order
  • Correct H chip for these years
  • Pre-installed batteries, pre-tested
Cons
  • Must be cut and programmed by a pro
  • Only for key-start models
  • Check G vs H chip on older cars
07 Best for Jeep
MechanMagic Remote Head Key for Jeep Wrangler, Compass, Patriot (OHT692427AA, 315 MHz)

A 315 MHz remote head key with a 46 chip for Jeep and Dodge models

315 MHz 46 chip Key ignition

This remote head key replaces FCC IDs OHT692427AA, OHT692713AA and KOBDT04A at 315 MHz with a 46 transponder chip. MechanMagic lists the 2007–2018 Wrangler and Compass and the 2010–2017 Patriot, along with the 2010–2012 Caliber, 2007–2011 Nitro and several other Dodge and Chrysler models.

It works only on key-ignition vehicles, arrives with battery and electronics, and is pre-tested with professional tools. A locksmith or hardware store has to cut and program it. Compare the button layout on the listing’s photos with your original before ordering.

Best for
Wrangler, Compass and Patriot owners
Not for
Newer push-start Jeeps
Pros
  • Wide Jeep and Dodge coverage
  • Pre-tested with pro tools
  • Battery included
Cons
  • Needs cutting and programming
  • Not for push-start vehicles
  • No brand logo on the case
08 Best budget
Discount Keyless Keyless Entry Remote for Nissan and Infiniti, 2-Pack (KBRASTU15)

Two basic remotes for older Nissan and Infiniti models with a key ignition

2 remotes Self-program Key ignition

If your older Nissan or Infiniti has a metal key plus a separate remote, this is the cheapest route back to keyless entry. You get two remotes that you program yourself using the included instructions, and Discount Keyless says each remote is tested. They replace FCC IDs KBRASTU15, CWTWB1U415, CWTWB1U733 and CWTWB1U821.

These are remotes only, with no key blade or transponder, so they lock and unlock but won’t start the car. They work only on vehicles with a standard key ignition, not push-button or twist-knob start.

Best for
Older key-start Nissan and Infiniti owners
Not for
Anyone who needs a key that starts the car
Pros
  • Lowest cost per remote
  • Self-programming instructions included
  • Each remote tested
Cons
  • Lock and unlock only, no key
  • Not for push-start or twist-knob Nissans
  • Basic plastic case
Reality check

Why some aftermarket car key fobs don't work

Most "it won't program" stories come down to a mismatch, not a faulty fob. Locksmith trade magazine Locksmith Ledger describes two identical-looking fobs where one chip was already locked to another vehicle and the other was blank, and a fob that carried a different model's part number. To the eye they were the same key; to the car they were not.

Other failures happen inside the car. Locksmith supplier Keyless City notes that some body control modules only accept a new remote through an exact procedure, that a programming tool can report success while the car ignores the fob, and that cheap clone chips can fail without a clear error. Mid-2010s Nissan Rogues and certain Honda models come up often in that kind of trouble.

Then there are the complaints that show up after a fob is programmed: weak range, short battery life, buttons that need a hard press, and a case that cracks. These are the build-quality gaps between the best aftermarket car key fobs and the cheapest no-name ones, and they are why we picked sellers that pre-test each unit and support what they sell.

Comparing an original key fob with an aftermarket replacement to check the circuit board and battery match

What to look for

How to choose an aftermarket car key fob that works

01
FCC ID and part number

The FCC ID is printed on the back of most fobs or under the battery cover. The part number narrows it further, because one FCC ID can cover several versions.

Look for
A listing that names both and matches your original.
Avoid
Buying from a photo or a "fits most" claim.
02
Frequency and chip

US cars mostly use 315 MHz or 433 MHz remotes, and the transponder chip (such as Toyota’s G or H chip, or a 46 chip) must match for the key to start the car.

Look for
Frequency and chip type on the listing.
Avoid
A cheaper fob with a different chip letter.
03
Board version on smart keys

Toyota and Lexus smart keys come with different internal boards under the same FCC ID. The wrong board will not program.

Look for
The board number (for example 281451-2110, AG board).
Avoid
Smart key listings with no board or part number.
04
Button layout

A 4-button fob can’t replace a 5-button key with remote start, and the remote-start button often has to be in the same position.

Look for
The same buttons in the same places as your key.
Avoid
Assuming extra buttons will add features your car lacks.
05
Programming route and cost

Some keys program at home with two working keys or a door-and-ignition routine; most smart keys need a locksmith tool.

Look for
A clear DIY procedure or a locksmith who will program customer-supplied keys.
Avoid
Ordering a blank before you know who will program it.
Cost

Aftermarket vs OEM key fobs: is the saving worth it?

An OEM fob comes from the carmaker's own supplier and usually costs the most at a dealer. Aftermarket fobs are made by other companies to the same specs, and some locksmiths also sell refurbished OEM keys in new shells. Listings that say "OEM style" or "OEM compatible" are aftermarket.

For most cars, a good aftermarket fob does the same job for much less, as long as it matches your codes. The trade-off is consistency: an OEM key almost always programs first time, while a cheap aftermarket fob may need a return. If your car is known for fussy programming, or you've lost every key, ask the locksmith which keys they trust before you order. Our replacement key fob cost guide breaks down dealer, locksmith and DIY prices, and our popular-vehicle roundup covers more models.

Step List

How to buy an aftermarket key fob that works first time

  1. Read your original key

    Note the FCC ID, part number, button count and layout, and whether your car has push-button start. You can look up any FCC ID in the FCC equipment authorization database.

  2. Match the listing

    Check the frequency, chip type and, for smart keys, the board number. Use the seller’s fitment tool or send your VIN.

  3. Choose the route

    Decide whether you’ll program it yourself or book a locksmith. Call ahead: some locksmiths charge more for customer-supplied keys.

  4. Program while one key works

    Adding a key is simpler while an original still works. See our guide to programming a key fob yourself.

  5. Test everything

    Check lock, unlock, trunk, panic and remote start, the range from across a parking lot, and that the key starts the car, before the return window closes.

Keep the old fob

Don’t throw away a broken original. Its FCC ID and part number are the best guide to the right replacement, and a locksmith may be able to reuse its chip or board in a new shell.

Frequently Asked Questions

Aftermarket car key fob FAQ

Do aftermarket car key fobs actually work?

Yes, when they match your original’s FCC ID, part number, frequency and chip. Most failures come from a mismatch or a programming step, not from aftermarket fobs as a whole.

Can I program an aftermarket key fob myself?

Sometimes. Basic remotes and some Ford smart keys can be added at home, often with one or two working keys. Most smart keys and all transponder blades need a locksmith’s tool or the dealer.

Will a locksmith program a key fob I bought online?

Many will, but some charge more or won’t guarantee a customer-supplied key. Call before you order.

Why won't my new key fob program?

The usual causes are a wrong FCC ID, part number, board or chip, a fob already locked to another car, or a missed step in the car’s programming procedure. See why a car stops detecting a key fob for more fixes.

Are aftermarket key fobs as reliable as OEM?

The better ones are close. Cheap no-name fobs are more likely to have weak range, short battery life or worn buttons, so buy from sellers that pre-test their fobs and offer support.

What if I've lost all my keys?

DIY programming usually needs a working key, so you’ll need a locksmith or dealer. Read what to do if you lose your only car key.

Conclusion

The bottom line

  • Match the FCC ID, part number, frequency and chip
  • Smart keys usually need a locksmith
  • Buy from sellers that pre-test and support their fobs
  • Add a spare while you still have a working key

The best aftermarket car key fobs are the ones built to your car’s exact codes. For 2013–2017 Fords, the Keyless2Go 5-button smart key is the easiest to add yourself. GM owners get the best value from Keyless2Go’s flip key, Toyota owners should match the board or chip as SUPALAND does, and the Mazda, Honda, Jeep and Nissan picks cover other popular cars. Check your codes, plan the programming, and an aftermarket fob can save you a large share of the dealer price.

General information only. Steps and features vary by make, model and year, so always check your owner’s manual. If you’re unsure, ask a qualified auto locksmith or your dealer. Fob Advisor is independent and not affiliated with any car manufacturer.

Affiliate disclosure. Fob Advisor is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. This never affects our advice. Learn more.

Found this useful? Share it:
FA

Written by the Fob Advisor team

We research every guide using manufacturer manuals, auto locksmith advice and real owner experiences, then keep it updated as cars and keys change. Spotted something out of date? Let us know.

Continue reading

About Fob Advisor

Free, independent help with car key fobs: batteries, programming, faults, lost keys and keyless security. Every guide is researched from manufacturer and specialist sources and written in plain English.

How we research ›

Still stuck?

Got a key fob problem we haven't covered?

Tell us your car and what's happening. We'll point you in the right direction or write the guide.

Ask a fob question